How Do Police Deaths in the Line of Duty Compare to Police Shooting Deaths of Suspects?
An Instagram post about the numbers uses a combination of outdated and misleading information.
| 12 |
A viral post from popular Instagram account @cloydrivers76 on Wednesday showed images from a segment about police killings in America from Laura Ingraham’s Fox News show:
The screenshots come from the June 3 episode of The Ingraham Angle, during which Ingraham cited the Washington Post as her source of information for statistics on fatal police shootings of unarmed individuals in 2019 and the FBI as the source of her statistic on police officers killed in the line of duty in 2019. The latter statistic is correct, though it doesn’t tell the whole story and does not serve as a good parallel statistic to shootings of unarmed individuals: 89 police officers did die in the line of duty according to the FBI, but of those only 48 were killed in criminal acts while the other 41 died as a result of accidents. Nearly half of accidental deaths were due to motor vehicle crashes, with further deaths coming from officers being struck by vehicles while walking, firearm accidents, drowning, and one death from being struck by a tire while assisting a motorist.
The Washington Post has maintained a database of fatal police shootings in the United States since 2015. Data collected by the Post shows 14 unarmed black individuals were shot and killed by police in 2019 and 25 unarmed white individuals were shot and killed by police in 2019. It’s important when reading this information to note, as the Washington Post database does, that despite the fact that more white people are killed by the police, black Americans represent a much smaller fraction of the American population. Census estimates for 2019 place the United States population at 13.4 percent black and 60.1 percent non-Hispanic white.
The Wayback Machine shows that on June 3 the Post database did not yet include four black victims of police shootings and five white victims of police shootings, meaning Ingraham’s presentation of the statistics were not inaccurate at the time her show aired. However, with more instances of police shootings from 2019 now logged, @cloyddrivers76’s Instagram post, published Wednesday, is promoting outdated information.
Photograph of Laura Ingraham by Gage Skidmore/Wikimedia Commons.
Mrs. Ingraham's dishonesty and the disservice she does to the Country is hardly surprising. Four hundred white Americans and 250 black Americans were shot and killed by police last year, a total of 1000 people were shot and killed, versus 48 police officers. Ideally no police officer should ever be shot and killed in the line of duty. Of the 1000 people shot and killed by police, 55 were unarmed. Ideally no unarmed person should every be shot and killed by police.
Oh, she's awful. I wouldn't trust anything she presents. Plus, I hate this numbers game. It's obvious there are too many corrupt police departments, too many abusive officers, and too many officers who protect the bad officers. Playing with the statistics to confirm a bias is just so awful when it comes to talking about actual human lives. The truth is we do desperately need police reform, starting with getting rid of police unions (all public sector unions) and getting rid of qualified immunity. Make each officer responsible for bad things that happen on their watch and maybe officers will be less likely to protect the bad actors.