Podcasts

A.G. Sulzberger on NYT, Objectivity, and Media Bias

The New York Times publisher A.G. Sulzberger  joins Steve Hayes and Sarah Isgur in a special interview recorded from The Times’ building in New York. They discuss Sulzberger’s recent CJR piece on objectivity in journalism (and its discontents), digging into the historically hostile relationship between right wing media and The Times, the challenges of fighting “bias” in news, and the possible paths to rebuilding public trust in institutional journalism.

Show Notes:

-A.G Sulzberger’s article for the Colombia Journalism Review

-Transcript available here

Happy Birthday, America

Trapped on the island of Nantucket, a guestless Jonah uses today’s Remnant to provide an impromptu meditation on the Fourth of July. His musings explore the meaning of the Declaration of Independence, whether America is a nation or an idea, and why it’s vital to teach American history. Listen with a hot dog in one hand and a miniature flag in the other to feel like a true patriot.

Show Notes:

Henry Fairlie: “The Shot Heard Round the World”

The Gettysburg Address and the meaning of the 4th

Irving Kristol: “The American Revolution as a Successful Revolution”

Calvin Coolidge on the Declaration of Independence

SCOTUS on Student Loan Forgiveness: Nope

For Advisory Opinions’ purposes, the Supreme Court term is over. Sarah and David return to share their end-of-term thoughts and feelings, David’s crankiness about the student loan forgiveness commentary, look to the next term and:
Student loan forgiveness is dead
D.O.E. v. Brown
Compelled speech in Colorado
NYT: I Teach at an Elite College. Here’s a Look Inside the Racial Gaming of Admissions

France Riots, Explained

A deadly police shooting in Paris last week sparked days of riots across the country. Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry, a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center, joins Dispatch Executive Editor Adam O’Neal to explain what led to the violence and where France will go from here.

Show Notes:
Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry’s profile at The Ethics and Public Policy Center

Reuters: France riots: Shot teenager’s grandmother says violence must stop

A Made Man

Rather than dedicating today’s Ruminant to another interminable rant about the state of the GOP (although if you’re interested in one of those, you might want to read Wednesday’s members-only G-File, hint-hint), Jonah focuses his attention on topics less likely to drive him utterly insane. These include some major recent Supreme Court decisions, his shrinking skepticism of horseshoe theory, and our tendency to overlook the meaningful distinctions between friends, family, and strangers. Tune in also to hear Jonah thoroughly dispel all rumors of his anti-Italian bigotry.

Show Notes:

The GLoP Culture podcast 

The Dispatch Podcast on the end of affirmative action

The Remnant with Bret Devereaux

Guy is released from the pit for a Remnant AMA

Jonah: “Defending Conservatism—From the Right”

Gertrude Himmelfarb’s The Roads to Modernity: the British, French, and American Enlightenments

Violence and Social Orders: A Conceptual Framework for Interpreting Recorded Human History

Let’s Go Coup-ing

Will the Supreme Court’s affirmative action decision in Harvard lead to a public backlash? What does the Coup That Wasn’t tell us about Russia (and about Americans’ changing perceptions of the war)? And will David French’s recent New York Times piece about transgenderism in women’s sports finally get him cancelled? Sarah, Jonah, and yet-uncancelled David French discuss.

Like what we’re doing? Please consider becoming a member of TheDispatch.com. You’ll be getting a suite of newsletters (including Kevin Williamson’s Wanderland, our news-breaking Dispatch Politics, and our flagship daily newsletter The Morning Dispatch), access to additional podcast episodes and exclusive shows, and be invited to members-only live Dispatch events. But most importantly: you’ll be helping us keep the lights on. So if you believe in our mission, we hope you’ll consider joining us.

Out of context: “I think I heard Henry Kissinger making the same point.”

Show Notes:

-Want the full legal analysis of SCOTUS’ affirmative action decision? Check out our latest Advisory Opinions.

-David’s NYT piece on the erosion of women’s sports

-Jonah’s G-File about isms, cultural cliches, and treat-yourself-culture 

Millennial and Gen Z economic malaise is creating a ‘treat culture’ as they turn to tiny purchases for a dose of daily escapism

Harvard Loses Affirmative Action Case

In a contentious decision, the Supreme Court shuts down affirmative action in universities… or does it? How impactful, really, is the decision in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard? It’s complicated. After weeks (months? Years?) of anxious anticipation, Sarah and David dig into this term’s blockbuster decision:

-Is this a big deal?

-They justices can’t agree about the universe of facts

-Harvard’s response

-The arbitrariness of check boxes

-A different kind of affirmative action

-Justice Thomas’ concurrence (and legacy)

-Justice Sotomayor’s dissent

-…paved with good intentions.

-Wonder Bread Alito

Pulling Teeth

Unable to find a guest who’s willing to tolerate his ramblings, an anesthetized Jonah is forced to return to the AMA format on today’s distinctly messy Remnant. Temporarily freed from his pit, Guy, Jonah’s immigrant manservant, offers a fresh batch of listener questions that cover everything from the latest in Supreme Court controversies, to the prospect of a Dispatch blogging section, to the conservative underpinnings of popular movies and TV shows. But although their conversation contains a few nuggets of genuine substance, most of it proves to be so pointlessly indulgent that you may be better served by simply listening to the week’s first episode again.

Show Notes:

-Watch: Jonah Goldberg AMA on YouTube

The Remnant with Bret Devereaux

Advisory Opinions on Alito’s preemptive strike

Justice Alito’s Wall Street Journal op-ed

Jonah: “Stop Pining for the ‘Good Old Days’”

The Daniel J. Boorstin Reader

Jonah discusses Patrick Deneen on the Acton Institute podcast

When in Rome

Jonah’s unwashed historical nerdery is usually unparalleled, but on today’s Remnant, he may finally have met his match. His guest? Ancient historian Bret Devereaux, who joins to discuss all things Roman. With topics including war and peace, political philosophy, and the cruelty of Spartan society, their conversation is sure to eliminate any misguided nostalgia you may have for the past.

Show Notes:

Bret’s pedantic blog

Bret talks Orc battle tactics on that niche legal podcast

Bret on Ancient Greece and Rome

Bret makes a correction on social conservatism

Steven Pinker’s The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined

Azar Gat’s War in Human Civilization 

Nuking the Independent Legislature Doctrine

As the term rushes to an end, the Supreme Court wades eagerly into a mooted case in order to close the door on the “independent legislature doctrine.” But does it matter? David and Sarah disagree. Also:

-Nobody expects the Marbury v. Madison citations

-What counts as threats online? (Or: Is recklessness subjective?)

-NYT v. Sullivan holds strong

-Supreme Court bingo: The Countdown

-Supreme (court) ignorance

-“You only defend justices Thomas and Alito because they’re conservative.” Nope.

Show Notes:

-Marquette Law School Poll

-Moore v. Harper

-Counterman v. Colorado

‘Nuclear War? Yawn!’

The Ukraine’s counteroffensive against Russia is underway, but what would it take to bring these two nations to the negotiating table? Foreign-policy scholar Walter Russell Mead joins Dispatch Executive Editor Adam O’Neal to share insights from his recent trip to Ukraine. They discuss:

-The normalcy of life in war

-What a “successful” counteroffensive looks like

-Opportunities for the U.S.

-The end of the Russian empire and a new nation

-(Unrealistic) theories of victory

-Engaging with nuclear adversaries

-How to get to the negotiating table

Show Notes:

-Watch: Adam O’Neal interviews Walter Russell Mead

Walter Russell Mead’s page at Hudson Institute

The Arc of a Covenant available online

-Walter Russell Mead’s page at Wall Street Journal

There’s Something About Marjorie

Saddened by hate mail and addled by a dingo-related health scare, Jonah’s in an exceptionally frazzled state of mind on today’s predictably excessive Ruminant. He begins his ramblings by addressing a crude spat between Lauren Boebert and Marjorie Taylor Green in the middle of the House floor before pivoting to some recent Russian war crimes in Ukraine. Then, it’s nerdery all the way down as he revisits last week’s G-File, which inspires a rant on the philosophical origins of liberalism, what defines American culture, and why there really is nothing new under the sun.

Show Notes:

The Remnant with Stephanie Slade

The Remnant with Robet Kagan

“Critical Trump Theory”

Alito’s Preemptive Strike (Against ProPublica)

Sarah Isgur and Guest-host David French return from the Advisory Opinions live event for some Supreme Court bingo. Plus:

-Opinion lightning round

-Justice Alito’s Op-Ed in the WSJ

-Transgender care for minors at the District Courts

A Race of Unpopulars

Steve and Jonah join Sarah to talk about Hunter Biden’s plea deal, how it reflects on Joe Biden and:

-Sarah’s first tattoo?

-Voters react to Hunter Biden’s prosecution

-The illusory Biden tapes

-Trump’s legally dubious Bret Baier interview

-Will Hurd jumps into the race

-Is RFK Jr. a sign that nature is healing?

-Biden Administration foreign policy

-Titanic submersible

Down In History

WARNING: The following episode contains multiple references to a certain American president who shall not be named. Due to the high volume of mentions, The Dispatch production team used discretion in playing the musical cue which normally follows all such mentions. We apologize in advance.

On today’s Remnant, Jonah is joined by Robert Kagan—leading scholar of foreign policy and senior fellow at the reviled Brookings Institution, where the sweet taste of candy never gets old—to discuss his new beach read, a 700-page history of America’s role in the world in the first half of the 20th century. Their conversation covers everything from the origins of the League of Nations to the wackiness of Charles Beard, with some fiendishly nerdy musings on isolationism, nativism, and conservatism mixed in for good measure. Predictably, Jonah does not make good on his initial promise to “not get too deep into the weeds.”

Show Notes:

The Ghost at the Feast: America and the Collapse of the World Order, 1900-1941

The Great Influenza: The Story of the Deadliest Pandemic in History

American Midnight: The Great War, a Violent Peace, and Democracy’s Forgotten Crisis

“Challenging the U.S. Is a Historic Mistake”

Taking Liberties

Patrick Deneen has released a new book, and predictably, Jonah has some pointed opinions on it. To critique Deneen’s post-liberal vision for American society and the political right, Jonah is joined by a returning Stephanie Slade, senior editor at Reason and noted liberty-lover. With furious agreement and ornery hand-wringing, they take a deep dive into the strange world of the new right, analyzing how seriously we should take its vision for the conservative movement. They also provide a few thoughts on the state of Catholicism, what the Dobbs decision revealed about voters, and why nobody can agree about immigration.

Show Notes:

-Watch: Jonah Goldberg interview Stephanie Slade

Stephanie’s page at Reason

Jonah: “Patrick Deneen’s Otherworldly Regime”

Stephanie: “Liberalism Isn’t Rule by Elites”

Stephanie: “The New Right Isn’t So New”

Stephanie: “The Rise of Right-Progressivism”

Adrian Vermeule: “Integration From Within”