Podcasts

The Great Wimpification

Jonah drops by Commentary’s New York headquarters and holds John Podhoretz hostage for an hour and a half to discuss the Jews, Suicide of the West, and the allure of fame and TV. Stay tuned for a history of Commentary’s geographical history (who asked?), the decline of American journalism (spoilers!), and optimism about the future (really?). Also, happy birthday to The Fair Jessica.

Show Notes:
“MIT ends Diversity Statements in Faculty Hiring”
Civil War (2024)
“The Collapse of the News Industry Is Taking Its Soul Down With It”
“Conservatives in the Mist” coverage by NYT
Jeff Goldberg’s loss is our gain

Originalism v. Common Law

Judge Edmund Sargus from the Southern District of Ohio joins Sarah and David to take on originalism and different means of constitutional interpretation.

The Agenda:
Brown v. Board of Education and the different judicial philosophies that can be applied to the case
—Originalism vs. common law traditionalism
—Challenges and limitations of textualism and originalism
—Landmark cases and the Supreme Court’s decisions shaping societal progress
—Interpreting ambiguous constitutional terms like ‘equal protection’ and ‘due process’
Thus ends DEI

Show Notes:
Plessy v. Ferguson
Rutan v. Republican Party
Bostock v. Clayton County
Loving v. Virginia
A blast from the past: Rep. James A. Traficant found guilty of corruption
David for the NYT: The Magic Constitutionalism of Donald Trump
Seceding from Secession: The Civil War, Politics, and the Creation of West Virginia
Fifth Circuit opinion from Judge Andrew Oldham

The Second Coming of Trump

Robert Costa, chief election and campaign correspondent for CBS News, joins Jamie to discuss what a second Trump administration would look like.

The Agenda:
GOP Rep. Dan Crenshaw’s previous Dispatch Podcast appearance and Costa’s response
How Trump pressured different Republican leaders leading up to January 6
—Steve Bannon’s motivation and role
—Trump’s ongoing legal cases and how they affect his campaign
—Trump’s possible VP picks

Show Notes:

NYT “Could Trump Go to Prison? If He Does, the Secret Service Goes, Too”

The Ruminant of Infinity

Spurred by Robert Kagan’s new book, Rebellion: How Antiliberalism Is Tearing America Apart–Again, and Thursday’s Remnant, Jonah spends the majority of this interminable episode responding to Kagan’s critique of conservatism, from contextualizing William F. Buckley’s role on the right to recounting the left’s history of intellectual anti-liberalism. Also, kudos to the frat bros who saved the American flag.

Show Notes:
Jonah’s Wednesday G-File
“Metabolic rift” wiki page
King-Slutzky answers questions
Gee Officer Krupke

The Cult of The College Protest

Can you compare the pro-Palestinian protests on college campuses to January 6? What about 1968? Or 2011? Sarah is joined by Jonah and Steve to debate these questions and discuss Trump’s Time magazine interview.

The Agenda:
—Nostalgia for the Civil Rights protests
—Do we have political parties anymore?
—Protests become violent
—Whose fault is this?
—No Jewish hummus
—The UNC frat bros’ Iwo Jima moment
Trump’s Time interview
Ron DeSantis bans lab-grown meat

Show Notes:
Kaitlan Collins interviews J.D. Vance on CNN
Serge Schmemann: Student Protest Is an Essential Part of Education
UCLA wins the award
Jonah’s Wednesday G-File
McKay Coppins: You Should Go to a Trump Rally
Ross Douthat: There Will Be No Trump Coup

Tears of Scrutiny

It’s a silent spring in Texas as Pornhub pulls out of the state in an act of protest over a law requiring age verification measures. Sarah and David go through the legal battle between the explicit site and Texas AG Ken Paxton.

The Agenda:

—Sarah’s high

Texas law requiring age verification to access pornography online

—The tiers of scrutiny in constitutional law

—The role of text, history, and tradition

Going through the Antisemitism Awareness Act of 2023

—Understanding the differences between Medicare and Medicaid can be challenging, even for lawmakers

Show Notes:

Sarah’s Remnant episode

Jacobellis v. Ohio

Ginsberg v. New York

Ashcroft v. ACLU

Child Online Protection Act

Wickard v. Filburn Wilker

United States v. Carolene Products Company

David for NYT: Ban Online Porn for Kids

David for NYT: One Party Has a Serious Foreign Policy Problem. The Other Has a Tantrum.

A class-action lawsuit against Columbia

Will the Real Anti-Liberal Please Stand Up?

Jonah is joined by Robert Kagan—a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and author of Rebellion: The Antiliberal Tradition That Is Tearing America Apart – Again—to debate Robert’s theory on the anti-liberal history of conservatism and why he thinks Trump is a logical product of the American right.

Show Notes:
Robert’s profile at Brookings
Robert’s new book
Why the South Must Prevail
Miles Taylor’s book, Blowback: A Warning to Save Democracy from the Next Trump

Korematsu and Vegetables

Jonah invites Sarah onto The Remnant to grill her on her sociopathic “subtweet,” debate the ethics of killing dogs, and peer into the minds of anti-Israeli student protesters. But for the main course, the two argue about Trump’s immunity case. Listeners’ discretion is advised.

Show Notes:
Sarah’s solo AO episode
David’s return to AO
Korematsu v. United States
Nick Catoggio’s Boiling Frogs newsletter on Kristi Noem
Centennial Crisis: The Disputed Election of 1876
Join The Dispatch for access to our exclusive Skiff feed

Pressing the SCOTUS Panic Button

David returns after a brief food poisoning hiatus to discuss two oral arguments heard before the Supreme Court: Trump’s immunity case and Idaho’s case on abortion bans. But first, a request from The Dispatch’s resident Wilson-hater.

The Agenda:
—Are solo podcasters sociopaths?
—Proposals for changes on the Israeli Supreme Court
Absolute immunity for presidents
—The role of the executive vesting clause
Reviewing Idaho’s abortion ban
—Time, place, and manner restrictions on college campuses
—Answering questions and issuing corrections

Show Notes:
Previous AO episode
South Dakota v. Dole
NFIB v. Sebelius
Dr. Martin Luther King on “civil disobedience”
Columbia University banned student protester over saying “Zionists don’t deserve to live”

Is Qatar an Arsonist or Firefighter?

Qatar hosts a major U.S. air base, but its patronage of radical Islamist terror groups has some Americans questioning the alliance. Jonathan Schanzer, senior vice president for research at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, joins Jamie to explain.

The Agenda:
—Introduction to Qatar
—Various actors and terrorist organizations in Qatar
—Qatar’s financial influence in Washington
Al Jazeera’s relationship with Qatar
Responding to Rep. Dan Crenshaw’s comments on Qatar

Show Notes:
Jonathan for The Jerusalem Post: Qatar: ‘The arsonist who then claims to be the firefighter’

All the Lonely People

Derek Thompson of The Atlantic joins Victoria to answer the question: Why did Americans stop hanging out? The two discuss the steep decline in face-to-face socializing, the rise of loneliness, and the fraternizing role of protests.

The Agenda:
—The decline of social institutions in America
—Smartphones’ effect on teenagers’ lives
—Women turning to pets
—Challenges of raising kids in the digital age

Show Notes:

Derek for The Atlantic: Meritocracy Is Killing High-School Sports

Derek for The Atlantic: Concerts? I’ll Pass

Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community

Watch this episode on YouTube

Stress the System

Jonah begins by ruminating on the Supreme Court oral arguments for Donald Trump’s immunity case and explains why he doesn’t understand how people could be sympathetic towards the former president. He then turns to the Heritage Foundation’s spat with Erick Erickson before getting to the Columbia protests and Elon Musk’s surprisingly apt observation on the oppressor-oppressed paradigm.

Show Notes:
Word of South festival
Advisory Opinions on the oral arguments
The Collision on the oral argument
Dispatch Podcast roundtable
Ukraine: The Latest with Jonah
Erick Erickson’s article on free markets
George Packer’s piece in The Atlantic
Elon Musk’s tweet
Columbia student who said Zionists don’t deserve to live

Indictment Watch: Supreme Court Hears Trump’s Immunity Case

The Supreme Court this week heard oral arguments for Donald Trump’s immunity case, and David has thoughts. However, he was too sick to join today so Sarah had to go solo (Ruminant style!), recapping the legal and political implications of the case, assessing the strength of the arguments and their significance for the future of our political system, and trying to imagine where we go from here in this bizarre election cycle.

The Agenda:
—Good and bad news for Trump
—What presidential acts are immune?
—Impeachment and conviction
—Going through the specific charges
—Can Trump stage a coup?
—ANSWER THE HYPOTHETICALS!
—Defining official acts
—The effect on Trump’s other cases
—The effect on SCOTUS as an institution

Show Notes:

Bonus Collision newsletter

Motion to Placate

Congress did their job—for now. Sarah is joined by Steve and Jonah on today’s episode of The Dispatch Podcast to discuss Speaker Mike Johnson’s successful passage of Ukraine and Israel aid and explain the intellectual history of the illiberal right.

The Agenda:
—Ukraine aid passed
—Heritage Foundation vs. Erick Erickson
—What is conservatism?
—Columbia protests
—Will history prove them right?
—Genocidal language at Columbia
—Looking Jewish

Show Notes:
Ukraine: The Latest with Jonah
Jonah’s recap of the Mike Johnson saga
Erick Erickson’s article on free markets
The Great Debate: Edmund Burke, Thomas Paine, and the Birth of Right and Left
Norman Rockwell painting
Why are we protesting?

Hillbilly Übermensch

Audio doppelgänger Chris Stirewalt joins Jonah on today’s episode of The Remnant to venture through the polluted backwaters of media conglomerates and uncover a whole host of “whataboutism” garbage: the rise of antisemitism on campuses, the media bias in covering these protests, and the terrorist chants coming from the mouths of these students. The two also opine on the faces adorning a far-right fecal Mt. Rushmore, including the likes of Marjorie Taylor Greene and Paul Gosar. They discuss more serious matters as well, such as the current snapshot of poll numbers and whether or not Stormy Daniels is a porn “star” or just an actress.

Show notes:
What’s the Matter with Kansas? by Thomas Frank
“What’s the Matter with Kansas?” by William Allen White
Chris Stirewalt’s Remnant episode with Tyler Austin Harper
Bloomberg: Biden Trails Trumps
Chris’ piece for The Dispatch on Nevada’s poll numbers
The Hill‘s election center
Nikki Haley voters in Pennsylvania
Gallup: Americans showing average enthusiasm for voting in 2024
Jonah’s appearance on a CNN panel with Lulu Garcia-Navarro
Students chant “Go back to Poland!”
Piece on Mike Johnson in The Atlantic

Columbia Professor: Terrorism Is The Point

Adaam is joined by Shai Davidai, an Israeli-born assistant professor at Columbia University, to discuss a viral moment in which he was denied entry to Columbia’s campus and how the university’s administration is failing to protect Jewish students.

The Agenda:
—Shai Davidai’s background, from Israel to Columbia
—The antisemitism he was warned about
—Dialogue with protesters
—The administrative involvement in the protests
Play-by-play of Davidai’s experience on Columbia’s campus
—Are Jewish students safe on college campuses?

Show Notes:
Davidai’s “Rape is never ok” tweet
Petition calls for Davidai’s termination
Davidai’s appearance on 60 Minutes
Rep. Ilhan Omar questions Columbia University president
Former Iranian President Ahmadinejad’s appearance at Columbia
Time to Condemn’s website
Resistance 101 event at Columbia
Joseph Borgen, Jewish man assaulted in 2021