Podcasts

Debating the Israel-Hamas War

Mehdi Hasan, former MSNBC host and co-founder of the media outlet Zeteo, joins Jamie for a heated debate about Israel’s response to Hamas’ October 7 attack and the accusations that the IDF is committing war crimes.

The Agenda:
—Laying out the current situation in Gaza
The issue of proportionality in the use of force
—Debating casualty numbers from the Gaza Health Ministry
—The feasibility of a two-state solution
The question of war crimes
The United States’ role in the conflict

Show Notes:

—WSJ: “Mansour Abbas Is an Arab and a Proud Israeli”

Goldfish Memories

Biden’s Losing the Vibe War

Jonah the usurper invites Kevin, Mike, and Washington Post columnist Megan McArdle on today’s episode of The Dispatch Podcast for some unfettered, wide-ranging punditry stretching from Biden’s wobbling support of Israel to the political implications of Florida’s abortion law.

The Agenda:
World Central Kitchen deaths in Gaza
—Biden’s balancing act between addressing concerns from the pro-Palestinian crowd and supporting Israel
—The Florida Supreme Court upholds the state’s six-week abortion ban, but the pro-life victory could be short-lived
California’s housing crisis and the state’s regulatory barriers

The Federalist Society in Peril

What’s Russia Planning

On today’s episode of The Remnant, Jonah attempts to live out his closeted dream of becoming an American spy by diving into a report titled “The Kremlin’s Occupation Playbook: Coerced Russification and Ethnic Cleansing in Occupied Ukraine.” He is joined by Karolina Hird, author of the report, to discuss the Kremlin’s heartbreaking tactic of deporting and forcibly adopting Ukrainian children, a ploy designed to alter the demographic fabric of the occupied territories. Hear about the critical issue of delayed aid to Ukraine, Russia’s strategic use of timing on the battlefield, and the strictly censored Russian media landscape that stifles authentic discourse on the conflict.

Show Notes:
Karolina Hird’s profile at the Institute for the Study of War
Interactive Map: Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine
ISW’s Ukraine Conflict Updates page

How Is India Doing?

In a refreshing break from rank punditry, Jonah is joined by Sadanand Dhume—a Wall Street Journal columnist and senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute who specializes in South Asian political economy—to answer the question: How is India doing? Dhume also gives a lesson on the religious demographics in India and how the caste system actually works.

Show Notes:
Dhume at the Wall Street Journal
Dhume’s book, My Friend the Fanatic: Travels with a Radical Islamist
Dhume: Indian Muslims Flunk the Israel Test

Federal Judges Examine the Israel-Hamas War

Federal Judges Roy Altman, Lee Rudofsky, and Amul Thapar join Sarah and David to discuss their recent trip to Israel along with 11 other federal judges that focused on the question of the day: Is Israel complying with international law as it pursues its war against Hamas in Gaza?

The Agenda:
—The purpose of the judges’ trip
—Walking through the locations of the October 7 attack
Gruesome tactics by Hamas
Military authority in Israel
—Israel’s legitimacy as a nation-state
—David’s JAG experience
—Double standards and antisemitism
The Jewish idea of gratitude

This conversation includes discussion of graphic content related to the October 7 attacks in Israel. Listener discretion is advised.

Gaza Changed Urban Warfare

Jamie is joined by John Spencer, an author, former colonel in the California State Guard, and urban warfare expert with 25 years of experience in the Army, to examine Israel’s tactics in Gaza and weigh in on allegations the IDF is committing genocide and/or war crimes.

The Agenda:
Joe Rogan accuses Israel of genocide
—John’s experience in Gaza
—War is not quantitative
—How to determine proportionality
“High threshold of civilian death”
—We are at war with ignorance
H.R. McMaster’s “zero-dark-thirty fallacy”
—Reception of his expertise in Ukraine vs. Gaza

Show Notes:
John: Israel Has Created a New Standard for Urban Warfare. Why Will No One Admit It?

The Mediocre Idiots of Monocausality

Jonah ruminates on the UN Special Rapporteur’s report alleging genocide in Gaza and the minimization of sexual violence on October 7. And if you weren’t day-drinking yet, he then kvetches about lousy concepts of social justice, the Ronna McDaniel-NBC News controversy, and the growing urge to oversimplify complex topics with monocausal explanations.

Show Notes:
UN Special Rapporteur’s report
ABC News report on random punching incident
Protests at Vanderbilt
Jonah’s LA Times article on October 9
John Spencer
The Remnant with Jonathan Haidt

About That NBC News Drama …

The hiring and firing of Ronna McDaniel at NBC News brought up mixed feelings for the staffers at The Dispatch. Sarah, Jonah, Steve, and David (French!) open up about their own complicated relationships with mainstream media, the problems with hiring partisans into newsrooms, and whether McDaniel is a good avatar for any of these questions.

The Agenda:
—Roles of ideological purity in media
—The crew’s experiences at their respective news outlets
Steve’s behind-the-scenes insight into McDaniel’s Meet the Press interview
—The changing definition of RINO
—The lack of truthfulness in news outlets
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s ballot-access dilemma

Show Notes:
Meidas Touch article on Ronna McDaniel hiring
Vox hit piece on Sarah Isgur following CNN exit

What the Abortion Pill Case Is Really About

The Great Rewiring of Childhood

Jonathan Haidt makes his long-heralded return to The Remnant to discuss his new book, The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood Is Causing an Epidemic of Mental IllnessHe and Jonah discuss the unique issues facing Gen Z and the mental health crisis brought on by the proliferation of smartphones and social media. And unlike many other public intellectuals, Haidt has solutions. In regular Remnant fashion, Jonah also steers the conversation into the differences between the French and English Enlightenment, and how understandings of human nature can affect how we parent.

Show Notes:
The Coddling of the American Mind
The Remnant with Rob Henderson
The Remnant with Tim Carney
What the Web Needs: More Gated Communities
New York Magazine on the freedom of sex
Hayek’s Nobel speech
Heterodox Academy website
Let Grow website
The Anxious Generation website

Grandma Was Right

Rob Henderson, a psychologist and author, makes his Remnant debut to discuss his new book Troubled: A Memoir of Family, Foster Care, and Social ClassGrowing up in poverty and moving through multiple foster homes in California, Henderson noticed a disparity between elite beliefs and the actual tools he used to climb the social ladder. The two explore this concept of “luxury beliefs,” our screwed up foster care system, the arguments for mandatory public service, and more.

Show Notes:
Rob’s newsletter
—Rasmussen report on Affirmative Action
The Remnant with Brad Wilcox
The Remnant with Tim Carney
Atomic Habits
Charles Murray’s review of Rob’s book

Judge Cannon’s Clerkship Problem

In this double-guest special, David Lat shares his original reporting on the exodus of Judge Aileen Cannon’s clerks and its implications for Trump’s classified documents case. Judge David Proctor of the Northern District of Alabama then joins to explain the history and function of the federal judiciary and its committees, including the Judicial Conference.

The Agenda:
Do younger clerks just not understand hard work?
—Judge Cannon’s declining reputation
Delays in Trumps documents case
—How the federal judiciary came to be
—Rule-making process for the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure
—Multi-district litigation and its criticisms

The Blindspots of Partisan Media

Brian Stelter, longtime media critic and author of Network of Lies, joins Jamie on today’s episode of The Dispatch Podcast to discuss the state of newsrooms nationwide in an age of ideological division, debate the blindspots of partisan media, and offer thoughts on the future of journalism.

The Agenda:
Overcorrecting coverage of Trump
—Trump’s influence on ratings
—COVID-19 coverage and school closures
—Reporting on race riots
—Forgetting 2020
—The New York Times’ newsroom culture
—Going independent and successful alternative media platforms
—Stelter’s take on what CNN should do now

Whigged Out

Jonah reaches new heights of self-indulgence on today’s Ruminant, explaining why he’s a soft Whig and why Romanticism is making everything worse. Devoted listeners will be quick to catch a whiff of Suicide of the West as Jonah veers to discuss the origin of identity politics and the structural resilience of liberal democracies. Have your bingo cards and German dictionaries at the ready.

Show Notes:
The Remnant with Allen Guelzo
Jonah: Days of Future Past
Suicide of the West
Orwell’s Notes on Nationalism
Wednesday’s G-File
The Remnant with Tim Carney