Is the GOP Just Waiting for a Fresh Start?

Whatever happens in Manhattan, weightier indictments might prompt Republicans to reject Donald Trump.

By
112
Former President Donald Trump appears at the Manhattan Criminal Court in New York on April 4, 2023.(Photo by Andrew Kelly/AFP/Getty Images.)

Now is a time of woe, not just for Never Trump conservatives, but also for the much larger group of Republicans who made peace with Trump once but dread having to do it again.

In fact, just going by my unscientific survey, the melancholy is worse for those Republicans who may have agreed with the Never Trump crowd in principle (and in private), but for pragmatic and professional reasons found it necessary to spend years eating the steaming bowl of unpalatable fare that fate had put in front of them.

But after disappointing Republican performances in 2018, 2020 and 2022, almost entirely because of Trump’s influence, a lot of these former accommodationists and transactionists have concluded—correctly—that Trump’s an albatross for the GOP.

For all the talk about how this indictment helps Trump solidify Republican support, it hurts his—and the party’s—prospects in 2024. People who voted against Trump in 2020—and against his most sycophantic disciples in 2022—are unlikely to suddenly change their minds about him because he got indicted for a scheme to pay hush money to an adult film actress. And contrary to the alternate reality peddled by Trump and his biggest fans that he is the voice of the American majority, more Americans dislike him than like him.

Create a free account
Access additional articles and newsletters for no cost, no credit card information needed. Continue ALREADY HAVE AN ACCOUNT? SIGN IN
112
By
Comments (112)
Join The Dispatch to participate in the comments.
 
  1. Avatar photo
    DougAz

    https://apnews.com/article/oklahoma-tennessee-florida-partisanship-polarization

    The Depraved Conservative Republicans power grab continues. When will the lesson he learned?

    As in Wisconsin, decent people will oust the Powerista...the Conserveritata.

    Collapse
  2. Avatar photo
    Earl King

    I sound like a broken record but it is true that any serious GOP politician has to ask themselves. Is Trump adding to his numbers or static or losing. Cleary he is not more popular....people generally don’t like bitter angry people. Yeah, ok they like a fighter, Trump problem is isn’t fighting anything other than just his ego....It will be a mistake that the GOP electorate will go down the Trump path for the sole reason they mistook Trump fighting for them rather than just for himself.....It is a bit cult like. Now is the Winter of our discontent.....Yeah I know, but it felt winter like today.

    Collapse
  3. Avatar photo
    BrettH

    Enjoyed the read, thanks Jonah.

    Collapse
  4. Joe1776

    The Georgia case and January 6 "coup attempt" cases are even worse legally and politically. In America it is not a crime to give political speeches even if what they say is false. And nothing he or his team said to Raffensperger is even close to criminal. He did not tell Raffensperger to get 11,800 votes. Rather he was telling Raffensperger he (Trump and his investigators) already have evidence that way more than that many were fraudulant. If you haven't read the transcript I recommend it because it is short and often misconstrued by the media. Trump may be wrong about what he is claiming in that call but there is nothing close to criminal.

    https://www.cnn.com/2021/01/03/politics/trump-brad-raffensperger-phone-call-transcript/index.html

    The classified documents case is likely at least as good as this Manhattan case legally. But if Joe Biden is not also indicted, lots of people will be very angry. If Joe Biden were also indicted I think it would be ok, but we all know they are not going to indict a democrat. The wheels of justice at the current DOJ does not move in that direction.

    Collapse
    1. Retired Prosecutor

      The classified documents case would not be about mishandling secret documents- which regrettably is apparently customary among our upper political class - but about Trump’s obstruction of judicially authorized efforts to retrieve them.

      Collapse
    2. Avatar photo
      Mudskipper

      There is NO evidence that Joe Biden knowingly withheld documents and lied about that fact. There IS evidence that Trump did exactly that. It is looking like he lied to his attorneys, telling them that he did not have documents that he indeed knew he had.

      Collapse
    3. Avatar photo
      DougAz

      Doesn't Braggs 34 felony counts in the Trump indictment mean anything to you?

      What criminal statue do you allege⁰ President Biden to have broken?

      Collapse
      1. Retired Prosecutor

        Bragg’s case is a bad joke. But the apparent obstruction of justice case the special prosecutor is building, regarding Trump’s apparent refusal to comply with attempts to retrieve classified documents in his possession, looks like a very good case to me.

        Collapse
        1. Avatar photo
          DougAz

          Quite a few former and current federal prosecutors disagree with you about Braggs case. Including here, our MsMsM.

          NYC handles numerous Financial crimes, I'm certain vastly more than other locations. Bragg alone has 29 Financial fraud indictments with 151 counts. Absolutely nothing unusual about the Trump indictment. Normal course of business. The Federal aspect is probably a red herring. There are many New York banking, tax and campaign laws. Of which Trump's CFO Allen Weisselberg was found guilty.

          I appreciate 2 things about your commentary. First I agree the special prosecutor case has more in plain sight heft.

          I also appreciate the lack of demeaning tone.

          Collapse
    4. Hikingguy

      And yet he sent his deranged fans to assault the Capitol. Funny how you forget that part. Keep making excuses for this walking orange dirt bag, though, if it makes you feel better.

      Collapse
  5. James Morphew

    I suggest that the #NeverTrump-ers don't convince anyone with their repeated "I told you so" gloating. Popular in some circles (such as The Dispatch?), but not particularly inclusive nor inviting.

    Collapse
  6. Avatar photo
    Ralph S

    Isn't it clear by now that Trump is not competent to administer his household let alone this country? The nonsense he is spouting about defunding the FBI and the DOJ without a plan for the critical services provided by those organizations underscore that these are the rantings of a madman. His entire victimization charade is intolerable. He has so outdone the woke folk in that regard. I bought that the democrats were out to get him when he was in office (and they still are). But Trump is more than capable of hanging himself than any democrat plat to destroy him. This is the numbskull that wanted to delete or change parts of the constitution for his own particular predicament. He doesn't seem to have respect for the executive office or the concept of public service. Shades of Alice in Wonderland. He is in a fantasy world where he only sees himself as being cheered. There is not a serious thought in his head regarding policy. But he is an ace when it comes to name calling.

    Collapse
  7. MB

    Agree as well. Please console your Commentary Podcast friends who appear very despondent....even more than their usual crushing morosity.

    Seems to me like the primaries are pretty far away and alot of shoes are going to drop between now and then.

    Collapse
    1. Krbrady1919

      I appreciate the phrase "crushing morosity," because I see it on all sides these days. In many ways, we have it better than we've ever had as a country and as a species, and yet many of us are perpetually miserable (and find ways to make money on that misery..)

      Collapse
      1. Lermanews

        “Crushing Morosity” don’t you get it that’s their bit.. and it’s usually pretty compelling especially these days

        Collapse
  8. David Schmidt

    Agree with Jonah's assessment. I would also add the old tired (but sometimes helpful) cliché: Follow the money. What I mean is it would be very helpful to follow how much money each of the declared Republican candidates start to amass. To win a nomination and general election, it will take hundreds of millions of dollars.

    I read today that Nikki Haley already has 11 million dollars. Not bad. Surprising to me, actually. Let's see what the others can haul in as well. Because the fact is there will be no defeating Trump unless Republican donors stop giving the Trump and start giving to someone that can actually win an election.

    Collapse
  9. Donnybrook

    I hope you are right, but we were all eyewitnesses to what happened on Jan. 6, and have also since learned that it was not some spontaneous event, but instead was planned well in advance. So if that was not enough to dump Trump, I'm not sure if anything other than seeing him behind bars will make a difference to his base or GOP pols. Doubling down seems to be the only acceptable response.

    Moderates and swing voters may be influenced by the current and possible future indictments, but GOP politicians are taking their marching orders from the MAGA base and right wing media, so it seems they are now tethered to Trump for better or worse (while secretly rooting for Smith and Willis).

    Collapse
    1. Avatar photo
      BloggerBarbie

      Do you really think seeing him behind bars will make a difference to his base? You're more optimistic than I am. They will be screaming for him to govern from Attica. (Though as a native of Wyoming County, I must say that would bring in some much needed tourism money... )

      Seriously, ever since 2016, the one thing I've agreed with Trump on is that he could shoot a guy on 5th Avenue without losing support. The difference being that he's triumphal about it and I consider it a major tragedy.

      Collapse
      1. Donnybrook

        Agree. One of Trump's greatest talents is spotting the weakness and moral failings in people and manipulating them accordingly. Of course it takes two to Tango.

        Collapse
        1. Avatar photo
          DougAz

          The 2nd are the weak and motally failing Trump voters naturally. Well then his sycophants in Congress and state government.

          Collapse
  10. John Mack mack

    I doubt if Trump will be tried in Georgia. Georgia has a Republican governor who no doubt has no great desire to take the stand and implicate Trump. If Trump is indicted there, the legislature will repeal or modify the laws under which he is indicted.

    Collapse
    1. Donnybrook

      There is already legislation in the works in GA to give the Legislature the power to remove DA's that they deem unfit. They might as well call it the Trump Protection Act.

      Collapse
Load More