Skip to content
What the ‘America First Caucus’ Debacle Revealed About Marjorie Taylor Greene
Go to my account

What the ‘America First Caucus’ Debacle Revealed About Marjorie Taylor Greene

The remarkable thing about this whole project isn’t its racism or nativism but its stupidity.

Marjorie Taylor Greene was readying her assault, like that legendary Anglo-Saxon warrior Canute the Great at Assandun. The QAnon-friendly first-term Georgia congresswoman, who was banned from any committee assignments shortly after she was sworn in, was poised to launch her “America First Caucus” with Arizona Rep. Paul Gosar, an anti-Semitic conspiracy theorist so odious that his siblings cut an ad in 2018 endorsing his opponent.

They were going to be legends. But they turned out to be “cucks,” an insult that crowd loves to use.

Punchbowl News got ahold of the “America First Caucus Policy Platform,” a seven-page document detailing what these modern-day Knights of the Round Table would fight for. Contrary to a lot of the hysteria, it doesn’t read like Mein Kampf or The Protocols of the Elders of Zion. It reads more like what Greene said it was—a “staff-level draft proposal” based on some Trumpian boilerplate.

Most press accounts focused on two passages as proof the American First Caucus was soaked in white supremacy. First, America should have an immigration policy consistent with “common respect for uniquely Anglo-Saxon political traditions.” Second, our infrastructure should reflect “the architectural, engineering and aesthetic value that befits the progeny of European architecture.”

That was enough for most Republicans, as well as the press and the Democrats, to rain fire on the whole project. House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy insisted the GOP is not the party of “nativist dog whistles.” This point might strike some observers of the last four years as a bit of a surprise.

“Racism, nativism, and anti-Semitism are evil,” tweeted Rep. Liz Cheney, the valiant leader of what might be called pre-Trump conservatism in the House. “History teaches we all have an obligation to confront & reject such malicious hate.”

Now, I come not so much to praise the America First Caucus but to bury them. The remarkable thing about this whole project isn’t its racism or nativism but its stupidity.

The most enduring Anglo-Saxon political institution was monarchy (though Anglo-Saxons were hardly alone there). The institution that was fairly unique to them was the Witan, a meeting of “wise men” or nobles whom the king would call upon for advice on important political questions. Many historians see the roots of parliamentary democracy in the Witan.

“It does indeed look as if the history of constitutional liberty has important beginnings in Anglo-Saxon England,” the late British historian James Campbell wrote.

Of course, Greene, who famously thought that Rothschilds and space lasers might have caused California’s wildfires, almost certainly does not know this—and probably none of her supporters do either.

And normally, they wouldn’t need to know it. Outside of a few Whiggish historians, nobody really cares, because our institutions aren’t “Anglo-Saxon,” they’re Anglo-American. Besides, our Anglo-American inheritance owes far more to France (James Madison cribbed a lot of our Constitution’s structure from Montesquieu), the great commercial Republic of Holland, and the ancient Greeks and Romans than to King Canute or Alfred the Great.

My point isn’t that these professional trolls deserve the benefit of the doubt or that their critics are wrong to assume “Anglo-Saxon” is a racist dog whistle. Any project Gosar (who is of Slovenian and Basque descent, by the way) is part of deserves no benefit of the doubt. My point is that these people are idiots.

Perhaps the staff-level poltroons who wrote this platform meant to say “Anglo-American.” Or maybe they spent too much time in internet chat rooms where “Anglo-Saxon” is flung about like so much poo at the monkey house.

They’re not just idiots. They’re also cowards. The whole shtick of this recrudescent nativist crowd is its alleged willingness to fight. Fight whom? Everyone: the establishment, the media, the deep state, the socialists and the allegedly Hebraic tentacles of George Soros.

In the fevered minds of Greene & Co., Republicans who cave to the architects of demographic “replacement theory” are spineless cucks.

But it was Greene who backed down, whining that “the scum and liars in the media are calling me a racist by taking something out of context.” She has since announced that she wouldn’t be launching her America First Caucus after all.

Ignorance is often the author of cowardice. If Greene and her fellow travelers seriously believed in anything, they’d know how to defend their claims. But when confronted with criticism from McCarthy, Cheney and the media, they surrendered like meek peasants before a feudal lord, unable to defend anything that can’t be reduced to a hashtag or an applause line delivered to a crowd of people who don’t know anything, either.

Jonah Goldberg is editor-in-chief and co-founder of The Dispatch, based in Washington, D.C. Prior to that, enormous lizards roamed the Earth. More immediately prior to that, Jonah spent two decades at National Review, where he was a senior editor, among other things. He is also a bestselling author, longtime columnist for the Los Angeles Times, commentator for CNN, and a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. When he is not writing the G-File or hosting The Remnant podcast, he finds real joy in family time, attending to his dogs and cat, and blaming Steve Hayes for various things.